NAVIGATOR HOLDINGS LTD

Ticker: NVGS CUSIP: Y62132108 Class: SHS

COMERICA BANK's Holding History (CIK: 0000901541)

Note: Option positions (PUT/CALL) are excluded.

Q1 2017

Shares 28,550 Value ($000) $355 Avg Close $11.45 Range $8.90 - $13.83

Q4 2016

Shares 29,372 Value ($000) $325 Avg Close $7.99 Range $6.43 - $10.20

Q3 2016

Shares 29,926 Value ($000) $226 Avg Close $8.33 Range $6.26 - $11.22

Q2 2016

Shares 18,310 Value ($000) $150 Avg Close $13.59 Range $9.97 - $16.30

Period	Shares	Value ($000)	Average Close	Price Range
Q1 2017	28,550	$355	$11.45	$8.90 - $13.83
Q4 2016	29,372	$325	$7.99	$6.43 - $10.20
Q3 2016	29,926	$226	$8.33	$6.26 - $11.22
Q2 2016	18,310	$150	$13.59	$9.97 - $16.30